Phil 4.11.19

7:00 – 9:00 ASRC TL

  • Continuing with the BAA
  • Fixed the acknowledgements section and updated ArXiv
  • Meeting/presentation with Wayne at noon
  • ML seminar, presenting robot stampede
  • Wound up having an impromptu meeting with Aaron M.

Phil 4.10.19

9:00 – 5:00 ASRC TL

  • Adversarial herding and density-stiffness in legislation LegislationHerding
  • Need to make ArXive version of the DfS paper
  • NASA Meeting
  • Pivot to BAA
      • Refamiliarizing myself with the Call “BROAD AGENCY ANNOUNCEMENT (BAA) TITLE:  MASTERING COMPLEXITY IN MULTI- DOMAIN COMMAND & CONTROL” BAA FA8750-18-S-7014
      • FOCUS AREA 3- Machine Intelligence – Harnessing the speed and scale of machines to exponentially increase human capacity to command & control in an increasingly complex battlespace. The complexity of MD operations will quickly exceed human capacity and will require machine reasoning to augment the human decision maker across all stages of the C&C Monitor, Assess, Plan, and Execute (MAPE) cycle.
    • CONTENT AND FORMAT:  Offerors are required to submit 3 copies of a 3 to 5 page white paper summarizing their proposed approach/solution. The purpose of the white paper is to preclude unwarranted effort on the part of an offeror whose proposed work is not of interest to the Government.
    • The white paper will be formatted as follows:Section A: Title, Period of Performance, Estimated Cost, Name/Address of Company, Technical and Contracting Points of Contact (phone and email)(this section is NOT included in the page count);
      • Section B: Task Objective; and
      • Section C: Technical Summary and Proposed Deliverables.

     

    • All white papers shall be double spaced with a font no smaller than 12 point.  In addition, respondents are requested to provide their Commercial and Government Entity (CAGE) Code, their unique entity identifier and electronic funds transfer (EFT) indicator (if applicable), an e-mail address and reference BAA FA8750-18-S-7014 with their submission.

Phil 4.9.19

7:00 – 9:30 ASRC PhD

  • Banging away at the paper. It’s starting to look less incoherent
  • Added a section to the mapbuilding that links back to the FTRPG framing
  • Aaaaaand it’s in! Need to make a version for ArXive now

Phil 4.8.19

7:00 – ASRC PhD

  • Meeting with Wayne and Aaron last night. Wayne doesn’t think the venue is right for the papers in the current form. Rewrite combining papers as a “using FTRPGs” as a source for science.
  • Still need a venue for the mapping:

Phil 4.6.19

Added a section on calculating belief terms in the trap room. And then worked on the paper for the rest of the day. It’s currently 7:45, and the first draft is DONE!

Sent drafts off to Wayne

Working on the lit review. Reading Foucault’s Of Other Spaces:

  • We are in the epoch of simultaneity: we are in the epoch of juxtaposition, the epoch of the near and far, of the side-by-side, of the dispersed. We are at a moment, I believe, when our experience of the world is less that of a long life developing through time than that of a network that connects points and intersects with its own skein. (Page 22)
  • Today the site has been substituted for extension which itself had replaced emplacement. The site is defined by relations of proximity between points or elements; formally, we can describe these relations as series, trees, or grids (Page 23)
  • …we do not live in a homogeneous and empty space, but on the contrary in a space thoroughly imbued with quantities and perhaps thoroughly fantasmatic as well. The space of our primary perception, the space of our dreams and that of our passions hold within themselves qualities that seem intrinsic: there is a light, ethereal, transparent space, or again a dark, rough, encumbered space; a space from above, of summits, or on the contrary a space from below, of mud; or again a space that can be flowing like sparkling water, or a space that is fixed, congealed, like stone or crystal. (Page 23)
  • Places of this kind are outside of all places, even though it may be possible to indicate their location in reality. Because these places are absolutely different from all the sites that they reflect and speak about, I shall call them, by way of contrast to utopias, heterotopias. I believe that between utopias and these quite other sites, these heterotopias, there might be a sort of mixed, joint experience, which would be the mirror (Page 24)
  • the study, analysis, description, and “reading” (as some like to say nowadays) of these different spaces, of these other places. As a sort of simultaneously mythic and real contestation of the space in which we live, this description could be called heterotopology (Page 24)
  • But these heterotopias of crisis are disappearing today and are being replaced, I believe, by what we might call heterotopias of deviation: those in which individuals whose behavior is deviant in re 1:ition to the required mean or norm are placed. Cases of this are rest homes and psychiatric hospitals, and of course prisons; and one should perhaps add retirement homes that are, as it were, on the borderline between the heterotopia of crisis and the heterotopia of deviation since, after all, old age is a crisis, but is also a deviation since, in our society where leisure is the rule, idleness is a sort of deviation. (Page 25)
  • Third principle. The heterotopia is capable of juxtaposing in a single real place several spaces, several sites that are in themselves incompatible. Thus it is that the theater brings onto the rectangle of the stage, one after the other, a whole series of places that are foreign to one another; thus it is that the cinema is a very odd rectangular room, at the end of which, on a two-dimensional screen, one sees the projection of a three-dimensional space; but perhaps the oldest example of these heterotopias that take the form of contradictory sites is the garden. We must not forget that in the Orient the garden, an astonishing creation that is now a thousand years old, had very deep and seemingly superimposed meanings. (Page 25)
  • Fourth principle. Heterotopias are most often linked to slices in time-which is to say that they open onto what might be termed, for the sake of symmetry, heterochronies. (page 26)
  • Fifth principle. Heterotopias always presuppose a system of opening and closing that both isolates them and makes them penetrable. In general, the heterotopic site is not freely accessible like a public place. Either the entry is compulsory, as in the case of entering a barracks or a prison, or else the individual has to submit to rites and purifications. To get in one must have a certain permission and make certain gestures. (Page 26)
    • This limitation is why it is possible to come to consensus in reasonable timeframes
  • The last trait of heterotopias is that they have a function in relation to all the space that remains. This function unfolds between two extreme poles. Either their role is to create a space of illusion that exposes every real space, all the sites inside of which human life is partitioned, as still more illusory (perhaps that is the role that was played by those famous brothels of which we are now deprived). Or else, on the contrary, their role is to create a space that is other, another real space, as perfect, as meticulous, as well arranged as ours is messy, ill constructed, and jumbled. This latter type would be the heterotopia, not of illusion, but of compensation (Page 27)
  • The ship is the heterotopia par excellence. In civilizations without boats, dreams dry up, espionage takes the place of adventure, and the police take the place of pirates. (Page 27)

Foucault’s Heterotopias as Play Spaces

  • Tim Hutchings – Western Oregon University
  • Jason Giardino – Games to Gather
  • However, if the game was set on the deck of an aircraft carrier, we might find Foucault better abled to address the significance of that setting through his interest in social and architectural spaces. A Magic Circle is created when players ‘other’ themselves for the purpose of a game, a heterotopia is created when ‘others’ find a space within a larger structure in order to engage their othered selves. (page 12)
    • We are using games to map structuctures in larger spaces
  • “Heterotopias have a specific function that is a reflection of the society in which they exist.” (Page 12)
  • A heterotopia exists within a larger architectural and social space but is apart from it. However, a heterotopia operates in reaction to this larger framework – it considers the world from the margins and found spaces between the controls and intentions of society as a whole. Dungeons & Dragons remains blissfully ignorant of the space which hosts it. (Page 12)
    • Our aim of using these collective and repeated actions to produce maps of both place and space, when combined with aspects such as the explicit acceptance of the IRB meet this requirement, I think.

 

 

Phil 4.5.19

7:00 – ASRC PhD

  • Fixed my bug in chain for producing graphs
  • Pinged Wayne for the final push schedule
  • Ping Dr. Bryson about JuryRoom for AI ethics? Done
  • Nothing on the schedule, so writing all day!
    • Closing in. Mostly the lit review and previous work to do

Phil 4.4.19

6:00 – 1:30, 3:30 – 7:00 ASRC PhD 1:30 – 2:30 NASA

    • Woke up early, so here we are
    • I have the permutation code running, but I don’t like it. I can tell the overall stability of the terms, which is really good. We go from the terms in one set: 
      ---------------- [('Group 1',), ('tymora1',), ('tymora2',), ('tymora3',), ('tymora4',)]
new_set = {'something', 'dragon', 'grogg'}, master_set = {'something', 'dragon', 'grogg'}, sub_channel_list = ['Group 1']
new_set = {'light', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'light', 'dragon', 'grogg', 'something', 'coins'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora1']
new_set = {'eyes', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'light', 'dragon', 'eyes', 'grogg', 'something', 'coins', 'barrier'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora2']
new_set = {'dragon', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'grogg', 'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora3']
new_set = {'platform', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'grogg', 'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora4']
    • To just two groups 
      ---------------- [('Group 1', 'tymora1'), ('Group 1', 'tymora2'), ('Group 1', 'tymora3'), ('Group 1', 'tymora4'), ('tymora1', 'Group 1'), ('tymora1', 'tymora2'), ('tymora1', 'tymora3'), ('tymora1', 'tymora4'), ('tymora2', 'Group 1'), ('tymora2', 'tymora1'), ('tymora2', 'tymora3'), ('tymora2', 'tymora4'), ('tymora3', 'Group 1'), ('tymora3', 'tymora1'), ('tymora3', 'tymora2'), ('tymora3', 'tymora4'), ('tymora4', 'Group 1'), ('tymora4', 'tymora1'), ('tymora4', 'tymora2'), ('tymora4', 'tymora3')]
new_set = {'light', 'something', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'light', 'dragon', 'something', 'coins'}, sub_channel_list = ['Group 1', 'tymora1']
new_set = {'eyes', 'dragon', 'something', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['Group 1', 'tymora2']
new_set = {'dragon', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['Group 1', 'tymora3']
new_set = {'platform', 'something', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['Group 1', 'tymora4']
new_set = {'light', 'something', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora1', 'Group 1']
new_set = {'light', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora1', 'tymora2']
new_set = {'light', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora1', 'tymora3']
new_set = {'light', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora1', 'tymora4']
new_set = {'eyes', 'dragon', 'something', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora2', 'Group 1']
new_set = {'eyes', 'dragon', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora2', 'tymora1']
new_set = {'eyes', 'dragon', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora2', 'tymora3']
new_set = {'eyes', 'dragon', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora2', 'tymora4']
new_set = {'dragon', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora3', 'Group 1']
new_set = {'dragon', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora3', 'tymora1']
new_set = {'dragon', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora3', 'tymora2']
new_set = {'platform', 'dragon', 'coins', 'barrier'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora3', 'tymora4']
new_set = {'platform', 'something', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora4', 'Group 1']
new_set = {'platform', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora4', 'tymora1']
new_set = {'platform', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora4', 'tymora2']
new_set = {'platform', 'dragon', 'coins'}, master_set = {'something', 'coins', 'barrier', 'light', 'eyes', 'platform', 'dragon'}, sub_channel_list = ['tymora4', 'tymora3']
    • As you can see, it settles very fast. I’d just like to figure out a way to get intermediate numbers out of it.
    • Creativity Machine
      • Summary – An artificial neural network that has been trained upon some body of knowledge, and then perturbed in a specially prescribed way, tends to activate into concepts and/or strategies (e.g., new ideas) generalized from that conceptual space. These continuously perturbed networks are called ‘imagination engines‘ or ‘imagitrons‘. If another computational agent, such as a traditional rule-based algorithm or, even better, another trained neural network is allowed to filter for the very best of these emerging ideas, in terms of novelty, utility, or value, we arrive at an extremely valuable neural architecture, the patented Creativity Machine. Optional feedback connections between this latter computational agent and the imagination engine assure swift convergence toward useful ideas or strategies. This new AI paradigm is vastly more powerful than genetic algorithms (GA), efficiently generating new concepts on mere desktop computers rather than on the computational clusters required of GAs. This generative neural network paradigm can and has been extended to whole assemblies of perturbed neural nets generating complex ideas as a multitude of neural modules watch, selectively reinforcing those notions offering novelty, utility, or value of any kind.
    • node2vec: Scalable Feature Learning for Networks

 

Phil 4.3.19

7:00 – 1:30, ASRC PhD 1:30 – 4:30 NASA, 4:30 – 8:00 PhD

Phil 4.2.19

A lot of the weekend – ASRC PhD

  • Most of the past few days has been putting together the iConference talk, which Aaron, Wane and I pulled off yesterday. I need to send Keith Marzullo the paper he was asking about, but I’d like to close the loop with Wayne first.
  • And back to the CHI play paper!
  • Generate permutation table for convergence of place terms by number of groups

Phil 3.28.19

7:00 – 1:30 ASRC PhD 1:30 – 6:00 NASA AIMES

  • Downloaded an amoeba eating a bacteria. Need to edit
  • Fixed some bugs in the analytic code and downloaded some images and text. There is banding in the space name embeddings, which is pretty interesting
  • Worked on the paper. I think I have an entry point now. It seems to be flowing nicely
  • Dungeons & Dragons Single Volume Edition By Gary Gygax & Dave Arneson
  • GOES-R AI Kickoff meeting
  • More work on slides. Incorporated Wayne’s comments (I think?). Also got the video edited

Phil 3.26.19

7:00 – ASRC PhD

  • BBC Business Daily on “essay mills”. Apparently 7% of students use these?
  • Got 8 results on the survey so far!
  • Add query on place/space/channel(?) terms to find post. It could be an iteration until the one post that returns the most terms is found.
  • Evolving place names. Remarkable how few passes it takes for convergence (of at least the first 3 terms):
    • Group 1: (12 new terms)
      • ‘goblin’, ‘fire’, ‘orc’
      • ‘orb’, ‘statues’, ‘see’
      • ‘grogg’, ‘troll’, ‘box’
      • ‘dragon’, ‘grogg’, ‘something’
    • Group 1, tymora1: (2 new terms)
      • ‘goblin’, ‘orc’, ‘see’ – 1
      • ‘orb’, ‘gate’, ‘statues’ – 1
      • ‘troll’, ‘box’, ‘grogg’ – 0
      • ‘dragon’, ‘coins’, ‘something’ – 0
    • Group 1, tymora1, tymora2 (2 new terms)
      • ‘goblin’, ‘orc’, ‘stairs’ – 1
      • ‘rope’, ‘gate’, ‘orb’ – 2
      • ‘box’, ‘troll’, ‘grogg’ – 0
      • ‘coins’, ‘dragon’, ‘something’ – 0
    • Group 1, tymora1, tymora2, tymora3 (1 new term)
      • ‘goblin’, ‘orc’, ‘stairs’ – 0
      • ‘rope’, ‘gate’, ‘orb’ – 0
      • ‘troll’, ‘box’, ‘grogg’ – 0
      • ‘dragon’, ‘coins’, ‘barrier’ – 1
    • Group 1, tymora1, tymora2, tymora3, tymora4 (0 new terms)
      • ‘goblin’, ‘orc’, ‘stairs’ – 0
      • ‘rope’, ‘gate’, ‘orb’ – 0
      • ‘troll’, ‘grogg’, ‘box’ – 0
      • coins’, ‘dragon’, ‘barrier’  – 0
  • Checking to see if changing the order looks different
    • tymora4 (12 new terms)
      • ‘orc’, ‘goblin’, ‘vines’
      • ‘orb’, ‘trap’, ‘statues’
      • ‘grogg’, ‘troll’, ‘box’
      • ‘dragon’, ‘coins’, ‘platform’
    • tymora3, tymora4 (1 new term)
      • ‘vines’, ‘orc’, ‘goblin’ – 0
      • ‘rope’, ‘statues’, ‘orb’ – 1
      • ‘grogg’, ‘troll’, ‘box’ – 0
      • ‘dragon’, ‘coins’, ‘platform’ – 0
    • tymora2, tymora3, tymora4 (4 new terms)
      • ‘goblin’, ‘stairs’, ‘orc’ – 1
      • ‘rope’, ‘gate’, ‘across’ – 2
      • ‘grogg’, ‘troll’, ‘box’ – 0
      • ‘coins’, ‘dragon’, ‘barrier’ – 1
    • tymora1, tymora2, tymora3, tymora4 (1 new term)
      • ‘goblin’, ‘orc’, ‘stairs’ – 0
      • ‘rope’, ‘gate’, ‘orb’ – 1
      • ‘troll’, ‘box’, ‘grogg’ – 0
      • ‘coins’, ‘dragon’, ‘barrier’ – 0
    • Group 1, tymora1, tymora2, tymora3, tymora4 (0 new terms)
      • ‘goblin’, ‘orc’, ‘stairs’ – 0
      • ‘rope’, ‘gate’, ‘orb’ – 0
      • ‘troll’, ‘grogg’, ‘box’ – 0
      • coins’, ‘dragon’, ‘barrier’ – 0
  • Made a really nice map. This is entirely based on data and patterns found by the software, just arranged using a human-assisted layout:

Map-1

  • JuryRoom meeting. Chris is getting the schema right, and is looking at IBM’s cloud service for hosting. We spent some time walking through the map. Panos is eager to read the paper

Phil 3.25.19

7:00 – ASRC PhD

  • Realized that the blue sky papers are only referenced by a link in the preface of the proceedings, so I think very few people will have read it. Going to make the slide deck review the paper first, then add in the rest of the content
  • Need to make a survey for past players asking them if a map would have helped, and what kind of map?
  • Added more mapping types. We now have
    • simplesimple
    • place-edgesplace-edges
    • space-edgesspace_edges
    • all-edgesall_edges
  • Create maps with linked spaces for each room for a “zoomed in” room
  • Need to play around with labeling nodes, but that may be after writing the paper. I think I’ll need a different mapping tool

FlatEarth

Phil 3.24.19

I think this is pretty good: Map!

Are conspiracy theories what mysticism looks like when it adopts the trappings of rationalism?

Added some exception handling for the sql calls:

except pymysql.err.OperationalError as oe:
    messagebox.showerror("pymysql.err.OperationalError", oe.args)
    return None

Downloaded the new Slack files. Had to handle the presence of gifs, and a few other db issues. Everything continues to look good.

Working on building the table, then the map. Here’s the first shot.

split_1 places: ['goblin', 'orc', 'stairs', 'vines', 'see', 'hit', 'arrow', 'fire', 'gate', 'behind']
	splt-chn_1of4-tymora1 spaces: ['guys', 'temple', 'guess', 'damage', 'hey', 'spell', 'axe', 'know', 'trees', 'move', 'come']
	splt-chn_1of4-tymora2 spaces: ['short', 'log', 'attack', 'feet', 'stealth', 'damage', 'morc', 'temple', 'axe', 'top', 'mindy']
	splt-chn_1of4-tymora3 spaces: ['coins', 'light', 'damage', 'shards', 'glass', 'steps', 'floor', 'need', 'poison', 'bow', 'sacred']
	splt-chn_1of4-tymora4 spaces: ['spell', 'glass', 'feet', 'perception', 'antechamber', 'shield', 'cast', 'hand', 'log', 'move', 'beyond']
	splt-chn_1of4-Group 1 spaces: ['eyes', 'bow', 'side', 'bit', 'looking', 'carefully', 'halfling', 'arrows', 'near', 'beyond', 'hand']
	common elements: set()
------------------------
split_2 places: ['rope', 'gate', 'orb', 'statues', 'across', 'see', 'side', 'around', 'pit', 'feet']
	splt-chn_2of4-tymora1 spaces: ['something', 'perception', 'hand', 'statue', 'floor', 'guys', 'ropes', 'switch', 'wall', 'tie', 'pull']
	splt-chn_2of4-tymora2 spaces: ['tie', 'wall', 'open', 'lever', 'gear', 'trap', 'hand', 'pitons', 'lightning', 'javelin', 'cross']
	splt-chn_2of4-tymora3 spaces: ['lever', 'trap', 'metal', 'need', 'floor', 'perception', 'statue', 'dwarves', 'hand', 'bar', 'large']
	splt-chn_2of4-tymora4 spaces: ['trap', 'guys', 'guidance', 'metal', 'statue', 'fountain', 'perception', 'appears', 'investigate', 'spell', 'coins']
	splt-chn_2of4-Group 1 spaces: ['anything', 'metal', 'halfling', 'gear', 'close', 'something', 'spell', 'statue', 'range', 'trap', 'hand']
	common elements: set()
------------------------
split_3 places: ['troll', 'grogg', 'box', 'chest', 'hand', 'open', 'gate', 'club', 'see', 'want']
	splt-chn_3of4-tymora1 spaces: ['rope', 'oil', 'fire', 'door', 'sleep', 'maybe', 'trolls', 'key', 'nice', 'around', 'feet']
	splt-chn_3of4-tymora2 spaces: ['dream', 'tiny', 'people', 'sleep', 'groggs', 'thing', 'eyes', 'turn', 'lets', 'need', 'group']
	splt-chn_3of4-tymora3 spaces: ['attack', 'damage', 'key', 'fire', 'need', 'lock', 'hit', 'torches', 'attacks', 'dwarves', 'know']
	splt-chn_3of4-tymora4 spaces: ['spell', 'stealth', 'guidance', 'sleep', 'hands', 'burning', 'cast', 'ready', 'attack', 'damage', 'key']
	splt-chn_3of4-Group 1 spaces: ['song', 'sing', 'trolls', 'running', 'feather', 'sleeping', 'looking', 'need', 'creature', 'come', 'face']
	common elements: set()
------------------------
split_4 places: ['coins', 'dragon', 'barrier', 'platform', 'something', 'light', 'woman', 'see', 'eyes', 'treasure']
	splt-chn_4of4-tymora1 spaces: ['blue', 'figures', 'enormous', 'coin', 'piles', 'appears', 'friend', 'around', 'full', 'wyrm', 'shall']
	splt-chn_4of4-tymora2 spaces: ['body', 'enormous', 'across', 'must', 'offer', 'mortal', 'gold', 'piles', 'die', 'near', 'within']
	splt-chn_4of4-tymora3 spaces: ['bridge', 'choose', 'insight', 'blue', 'know', 'gold', 'bridges', 'appears', 'die', 'enormous', 'game']
	splt-chn_4of4-tymora4 spaces: ['stay', 'across', 'must', 'dragons', 'game', 'boy', 'enormous', 'gold', 'piles', 'cant', 'hear']
	splt-chn_4of4-Group 1 spaces: ['grogg', 'looking', 'anything', 'thing', 'troll', 'dragons', 'moment', 'gate', 'gold', 'breath', 'magical']
	common elements: set()

A really interesting thing happened in the run last night. There was an argument about the shared perception of the belief space in the troll room. This misalignment was with the DM (the longer smear), who is kind of like a ship’s captain and is the final authority of the dungeon. When the player resists adhering with the DM’s perception of the belief space, the DM threatens expulsion. Some explorers are born, but involuntary explorers can be made:

Outcasting_process